So... any ideas about who we really are?

Ahh Daemon Spanking, A truely fruitful hobby

"And Blend..."

hahahaha deamon spanking, nice one andy.

But i was first With the spanking!

*Tears fill my eyes*

Ok can we agree that the Codex Daemonhunters is fact.

Right ok now that is out the way this is what it says:

"the Grey Knights were unique in that their gene-seed was said by some to have come from the Emperor's own flesh"

There you have it from the codex.

True, straight from the source no arguing with that.

the Grey Knights were unique in that their gene-seed was said by some to have come from the Emperor's own flesh

Said By Some? Lol

My freind, That is just a way of getting people to collect Daemonhunters. It gets people that have never played the game thinking; Wow an army made from the Emporer of Mankind. Its a ploy. Besides, that isn't even conclusive evidence, "Said By Some" Some could be any-one it could just be from a random Hobo from the Slums of Terra, It could be some random school child. It could be a recruit from the Imperial Army. That is no evidence; "Some" isn't specific enough to make it evidence.

Well the "some" people you mentioned wouldn't even know grey knights exist, and if you ever see one, you are in alot of trouble!

The "some" could be inquisitors and ordo scribes or something.


But yeah, Some people saying isn't proof. But mutch better than beeing a traitor!

But sureley it is greater proof than the speculation that Grey Knights are from Garro, I am not sayng that I disagree just going on pure evidence.

Actually both are speculation hmmmmm. htink Garro et all were founders of Inquistion, Ordo Malleus etc but still think GK's closer to the Emperor than most a his DNA used and he could always have given himself a gene seed, hell all Space Marines are human first maybe Emperor was the first ever to have surgery in that way.

That would explain why he was more powerful than the primarchs, i wouldn't create (is it 20) a bunch of demigods if i wouldn't be able to bash them if i had to!

And gene seed should be possible to extract without progenoid glands inserted, as the only thing the progenoid glands do is to gather gene seed from the space marines body.

It could be Custodes gene seed (If they have that, or wait, i just explained that you might not even need progenoid glands to get gene seed)

Progenoid glands are there for easy removal, i think the apothecaries had to be a bit more numerous if you had to do a 3 hour surgery every time a marine dies to get his gene seed.

Instead, you can just slam the narthesium/reductor into the marines back and whop!!! Progenoid glands with gene seed! In less than a minute!

GW will make us discuss wether we como from Garro, the emperor or Sigmar itself, they will never give us more info because that would propably means deceiving somo players (sorry man, your warriors are not direct geneseed from the big cheeze)
I think If they ever give more info it will be either on novels (like Garro) or on a new dex, until then we stay only on hypotetic grounds.

Yes, the origin of the grey knights should be forever lost.

But that lost thing should be the emperor's own geneseed.

I second that!

For starters, The emperor has no gene-seed. The Emperor created the gene-seed. He used his own DNA to create the primarchs (And the custodes)

Legion of Light, In the quote you put from Wikipedia, you highlighted the part that states It is Thought that they were the original founders of the Grey Knights. The word "thought" is just as baseless as "Said by some" When Malcador the Sigilite said "We need people of an inquistive nature..." Think about that. Inquisitive. Grey Knights do not ask questions. They destroy daemons. Inquisitors ask questions. The only question a GK may ask is "Where are they?"

As far as the gene-seed is concerned. One thing people are forgetting is that Garro's gene-seed is actually that of Mortarion's as Qruze is that of Horus'. Do you honestly think after all the of that, the imperium would want to use the gene-seed of traitor primarchs. They're paranoid enoughas it is. I can see Garro, Qruze, Keeler and the Sister of Silence starting the different ordos of the =]I[= but not the Grey Knights.

Better that it remain a mystery

I also thinks the Eisenstein dudes start the inquisitions more specified orders.

And that the emperor is awesome enough to create geneseed from himself and put it in grey knights.

And of course, no one knows anything about any of this.

Becouse it's a secret!